The Ballad of the Black and White Cookie

Look at that layer of frosting!

This nasty Fall weather has me in a real slump. The rain really dampens my days, literally and figuratively. The fact that everyone on campus seems to have developed a case of the black lung this past week has me rather paranoid as well. All this ballyhoo over swine flu has me in quite the tizzy. So what are you suppose to do when the world is collapsing around you? Eat comfort food! For me, that means hearty soups and sweets. And since I don’t have a stockpot here at Tufts, I took the dessert route.

I made a plum upside down cake using recipe I provided for you earlier. It was decent, but the plums lacked flavor. I wanted peaches, but the grocery store (read: the cafeteria) didn’t have any.

Curse ye Dewick Hall for not having more flavorful fruit to steal!

Curse ye Dewick Hall for not having more flavorful fruit to steal!

I decided that a trip to a bakery would put some much-needed pep in my step. So on Sunday, I ventured over to Lyndell’s Bakery on Broadway. This shop has been around almost as long as Somerville itself. Since its opening in 1887, Lyndell’s has changed hands only 4 times. Pretty incredible. Lyndell’s still has that old school 1950s feel, which was a nice change from the hipster/gourmet vibe thrown off by so many other places these days. My trip to this venerable establishment proved to be quite successful. I ordered one black and white cookie and a cupcake.
The cupcake (chocolate with vanilla frosting) was a little dry for my liking, but at $1.25, it was hardly a financial fiasco. The buttercream frosting was quite nice. The real treasure was the Black and White cookie.

Inside of Lyndell's
I’ve never enjoyed B&W cookies (or half moon cookies, as they’re known to some), but that hasn’t stopped me from ordering one at every bakery I visit. Most often, the ratio of cookie to icing is disappointingly large. I’m a guy who needs his icing. The flavor of the icing is rarely suspect; it’s the cake gets fudged up. It should have the texture of a cake, but a lot of places ruin it by cookifying (yes, as in to cookify—make or become a cookie) the cake. Yes, it’s called a cookie, but that’s not the point! I’ve been places that flavor the cake—I’m looking at you Mike’s Pastries. Mike thought it would be a great idea to turn it into lemon cake. So lame, Mike. You’re lucky you make really freaking good canolis, or there’d be hell to pay. Maybe it has to do with region. After all, B&Ws started in New York.
This ain't yo daddy's fondant icing!
Well, Lyndell’s prides itself on its B&W cookies, so I figured I’d give ‘em a try. The first thing I noticed was the thick layer of frosting. Even without taking a bite, I knew this was gonna be tasty. After admiring the beauty of it for a good minute or so, I dove in mouth first, taking a bite right along the frosting meridian. The frosting was more of a buttercream than a traditional fondant. While this may not be wholly traditional, I didn’t take umbrage because the frosting was just so good. The cake, which was fluffy and moist, had had a sugar coating on the bottom. This crunchy layer texturally contrasted well with the rest of the cake. This small detail took the cookie to a whole different dimension.

Best of all, the cookie cost me a mere $1.75. This is a full dollar cheaper than a Kickass Cupcake, and like three dollars less than a JP Licks ice cream, so it leaves your wallet and your belly full! So next time Fall–or anything really–has you down, just hit up 720 Broadway here in Somerville.

Falling leaves=trees on chemo. And where's the fun in that?

Falling leaves=trees on chemo. And where's the fun in that?

One Response to The Ballad of the Black and White Cookie

  1. […] favorite!); however, I haven’t found anything on their menu that I enjoy as much as those “half-moon” cookies. Sundae, Bloody Sundae: Hot Fudge Sundae with Cookie Dough […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: